Dearth: noun; lack, a scarcity of something.
I am not implying that we do not have enough "American Christianity," but that, regarding what we have, it is lacking something. I know, I know. Just about every book you read on the present state of the church starts with, "10 Reasons Why the Church is Dying," or, "We're Losing Our Nation for God," or, "Everything's Falling Apart and It's Probably Your Fault." It's a great hook that Christian writers use to get you to read their book. They start with several chapters about what is wrong with the church, culture, theology, or you, and after you have gazed at the horizon from the top of their particular soap box, they then guide you through the shelves of their solution oriented merchandise. In about 250 pages they have identified the problem and have properly led you to their tidy fixes. Authors, pastors, and speakers are constantly hawking their magic potions to restore our marriages, churches, witness, and effectiveness in a myriad of areas. I am regularly being told how I should be doing more in every area, what I should do to help my church to grow, how I can be a better person, and how I can solve all my problems. When Scripture is used, it is used to show me what is possible and how far away I am from that goal. Again, the opening chapters tell me what the problem is, and the latter chapters point me to the solution. Well, I know that there is a problem, and I don't need Dr. So and So's book for $17.95 to tell me so. But, sometimes the search for solutions IS the problem.
I understand that the methods these authors and speakers use are basic rules of rhetoric and they are how we have learned to advance our arguments. These tactics also seek to asuage the nagging feeling within us that there is something not right by comforting us with a simple diagnosis and prescription for the problem. Dr. Danny Akin of Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary sought to do the same thing for us regarding the problems in the SBC when he gave us "The Eight Theological Essentials for Southern Baptists in the 21st Century." Here they are:
- The non-negotiable of a regenerate Church (John 3; Rom. 3; 2 Cor. 5; Gal. 3)
- The essential nature of believers baptism by immersion with a biblical appreciation for its significance. (Matt. 28; Acts, Rom. 6)
- The recovery of the lost jewels of church discipline and genuine disciple-making as essential marks of the Church.
- The emphasis and practice of a genuinely Word-based ministry (2 Tim. 4:1-5)
- The vision for a faithful and authentic biblical ecclesiology (Acts. 2; Eph. 4; Pastorals)
- The continued nurturing of a fervent missionary and evangelistic passion that is wedded to a healthy and robust theology (1 Thess. 1; Eph. 4:11-16; Jude 3-4; Rev. 5)
- The teaching and preaching of a 1st century biblical model for church planting (Acts 17)
- The wisdom to look back and remember who we were so that as we move forward we will not forget who we are
These points are elaborated upon on Tom Ascol's blog. Don't get me wrong, I think that these are all great things and I am fully in favor of them. We need to faithfully practice all 8 of these points, because they are right and Biblical. But, the implication, whether it is intentional by the speaker or not, is that these steps will fix our problems. And underlying all of our best intentions, methods, and approaches to life and ministry, the question must be asked from time to time: Why are we doing all of this?
Over time, I've come to believe that our motives are almost always mixed. I feel like that to be properly understood here I have to give a thousand qualifiers, like, "We should do evangelism," or "Happy marriages are important." But, I'm going to just save some time and skip it. I am fundamentally beginning to believe that what lies behind much of our effort and energy to be holy, have a great marriage, build a great church or a powerful evangelistic ministry, take our nation for Christ, and have revival is a profound insecurity and desire to have things our way so that we will be satisfied, safe, and justified in our "rightness." At least that is much of what I see in the South. In that, we are not much different from the Pharisees of old.
The Pharisees during Jesus' day were all about purity and separation. They wanted Israel to be holy and to completely obey the Law. The idea of blasphemy or idolatry or Law breaking was anathema to them, and they fully prosecuted anyone who got close to doing so. But, lying behind their pious intentions was a blatant fear that God was going to punish them and a belief that if they did everything right, then their autonomy as a nation from the Romans would be restored. The lesson that they learned from the Babylonian Captivity was that worshipping idols causes you to lose your nation and become slaves, therefore, you should not worship idols. But, the greater commandments such as loving God and others were lost upon them because their primary focus was their own security, safety, and happiness. I think that it is often the same with us.
Do we really focus so much on evangelism and missions because our hearts are broken for the lost and God's love is pulsing through us, or because we want to see our churches full so that we'll feel better about ourselves and our success, and so that we can have confidence that God is pleased with us and is blessing our ministry? I've been in churches where everyone was excited and really worshipping God when there were a lot of people there, but when the crowd was low, everyone was depressed. Why is that? I think that large crowds and a big following for our ministries make us feel like we are significant and like God is pleased with us. As if there were not other ways that we could know that (Romans 5:8 "But God demonstrates His own love for us in this: While we were yet sinners, Christ died for us.").
In Dr. Akin's Eight Points, I see no mention of Jesus or relying upon the power of the Holy Spirit. Paul said, "When I came to you, brothers, I did not come with eloquence or superior wisdom as I proclaimed to you the testimony about God. For I resolved to know nothing while I was with you except Jesus Christ and him crucified. I came to you in weakness and fear, and with much trembling. My message and my preaching were not with wise and persuasive words, but with a demonstration of the Spirit's power, so that your faith might not rest on men's wisdom, but on God's power." - 1 Corinthians 2:1-5. Paul pretty much lays out the impetus and power behind his ministry. Yet, I have NEVER heard that text proclaimed as a truth that we need to focus on. Is it too difficult to focus on and fall in love with Jesus? Is it too difficult to have a passion for God be our focus? Do we tell people to ONLY preach Christ crucified? What does that mean? What if our ministries ended up like the prophets of old, or even like Jesus' when he died on the Cross? We are so focused on size, results, power, and effectiveness that we have forgotten what it is to truly walk with the Lord. People are not coming to our churches because we have nothing to offer them. If a walk with the Lord is described by most preachers, it is generally described in terms of what sins we are not to committ, rather than in a positive nature of having our hearts filled with the wonders of God. If trouble comes, there is an immediate fear that we have done something wrong, rather than an understanding that this world is difficult, sin plagued, and full of death and we happen to live in it. We will suffer, but we have a Savior! We are giving people a Christianity that is focused on our needs, happiness, and contentment, while training ministers to put their faith in methods, structures, and right behaviors as though we could call down God's blessing through our effort and ability, instead of through a dependence upon the Spirit's power. Are we broken over our self-sufficiency? Are we yearning for God and the pleasure of His presence? Are we broken over the lostness and emptiness of the people around us? What are the motives that lie behind our actions?
As we near Easter, I have been thinking a lot about the Pharisees and the Jews of Jesus' day. And, I have realized that I am just like them at times. I have tried to use God to get my way, gain significance, and be happy and fulfilled. I have wanted Him to bless what I am doing and I get my worth from revelling in that blessing. I have often wanted to be first in relationships and the Kingdom, instead of following Jesus' words when he said, "For he who is the least among you all - he is the greatest" (Luke 9:48). But, God will not be used - He will only be worshipped. He will tear everything out of us that we have relied upon Him for, until we only desire Him. He is not our "God in a box," that we can bring out whenever we want something and so that our lives will be alright and our churches will function properly. He is God and there is none like Him.
The dearth of American Christianity is that the Jesus of Bible is rarely seen. The power of the Gospel that transforms selfish sinners into selfless saints has been exchanged for easy steps to Heaven and Your Best Life Now. And, this is even true in our very conservative churches that focus on expository preaching and church discipline if those things are just a means to some other end besides Christ. We desperately need Jesus, yet we always seem to run to something else that is good, but is one degree off of The Center. Over time, that one degree takes us miles away, and we wonder why we are so parched, weak, and worn out. The answer is not found in a new method, strategy, or blessing, but in returning to a place of affection and dependence upon our Savior for everything, with His glory as our desire and a sacrificial love for others as our activity. Colossians 1:17 says, "He is before all things and in Him all things hold together." Do we really believe that?
I know that I've been preaching in this post, and few of you have probably read this far (I understand that I broke most of the rules for blogs by writing a really long post). Fewer still will leave comments because we rarely take time to process such things. But, I want to encourage each one of us (I think I write more for myself to have the right focus than anything else) to focus on Jesus, live for His glory, and really think about what it means for us to be the least amongst the brothers, to suffer and join in with others who are suffering, and to take the worst seat and to be a servant to all. That might be considered to be a given, but it is a given that we rarely talk about anymore in our desire for effectiveness, happiness, and growth. So, "Let us fix our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfector of our faith, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, scorning its shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God. Consider him who endured such opposition from sinful men, so that you will not grow weary and lose heart" (Heb. 12:2,3).
What do you think? Better yet, what will you do?